REALWorld Law

Corporate vehicles

Permanent establishment

Does the concept of a 'permanent establishment' apply when a foreign person invests in real estate and, if so, how much does it cost to set up such a permanent establishment, how long does it take and what corporate governance requirements apply?

UK - England and Wales UK - England and Wales

UK - England and Wales

The term permanent establishment is not a generically used term in the UK (of which England and Wales form a part), other than for double-tax treaty purposes where the concept is relevant to the tax rights of the state in which a permanent establishment has been created.

Generally, for tax reasons, investors who are not resident in the UK would seek to avoid creating a permanent establishment in the UK.

Limited Partnerships

The use of a UK limited partnership for inward property investment is not normally seen as the creation of a permanent establishment for UK tax purposes.

The basic cost of setting up a limited partnership is often minimal. There are, however, additional costs such as taking legal and tax advice on whether this is an appropriate vehicle and structure and substantial costs will be incurred in drafting and negotiating (where necessary) a suitable constitution for the investment vehicle which regulates the rights and obligations of the investors and as between the investors and the sponsor or investment manager.

A UK limited partnership can be established simply by lodging the relevant details with the UK Companies Registry. However, the establishment of an investment vehicle with negotiated terms which will be suited to investors and the raising of funding from investors for that investment fund may take considerable time and the relationship and rights and obligations between the partners is usually governed by a limited partnership agreement.

A UK limited partnership is generally considered a tax transparent vehicle with taxation applied at the level of the limited partners, to profits / losses that are received by said limited partners from the limited partnership.

Limited companies

 UK limited companies are not tax-efficient vehicles for non-UK real estate investors since they are not tax transparent. One notable exception is the UK Real Estate Investment Trust, which is a company typically listed on a recognised stock exchange.

Where a permanent establishment takes the form of a UK incorporated company, UK company law applies, under the Companies Act 2006 and associated implementing regulations. This provides a comprehensive code governing the rights and obligations of the company itself, its directors and shareholders.

Certain aspects of company law relating to registration and accounts apply to non-UK incorporated companies with branches in the UK.

Limited liability partnership (LLP)

Where a LLP is used, this will be governed largely by the members' agreement, which regulates the rights and obligations of the LLP itself (which is a corporate entity in its own right with separate legal personality) and its members. The LLP will often be managed by a management committee of members who report to the membership at large. Although it is a corporate entity, an LLP does not have a share capital and is generally tax transparent for UK tax purposes. The Limited Liability Partnership Act 2000 and associated implementing regulations (the LLPA), provide the statutory framework within which LLPs operate, including rules on insolvency and measures for the protection of creditors. The LLPA contains many analogous provisions to those that apply to limited companies with certain modifications.

Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA)

The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) applies to all "regulated activities" carried on in the UK and can apply to a UK incorporated company, an LLP and a company incorporated outside the UK with a UK branch. Regulated activities include so far as relevant to inward UK property investment:

  • setting up and operating investment funds;
  • arranging deals in investment funds and other FSMA regulated investments;
  • the provision of investment advice;
  • the provision of discretionary investment management services; and
  • the dissolution and winding-up of investment funds.

Though direct real estate investment is generally not governed by FSMA, where property is owned through any kind of corporate or collective investment scheme vehicle, there will be FSMA implications and specialist advice should be taken.